History of Dr. George J. Fisher with the Boy Scouts

Posted on February 15th, 2024 in Adult Position Badges,BSA Info by ramore

We just took our 400,000th picture of Scout patches. It was of the National Commissioner patch issued and warn by Dr. George J. Fisher. Dr. Fisher was instrumental in the development of the Boy Scouts of America serving as the first Deputy Chief Scout Executive (DSCE) to the first Chief Scout Executive James E. West. Fisher served as DCSE from 1919 to 1943 when he retired from the Scouts. Upon retirement he was named National Commissioner, the first since Dan Beard.

Dr. George J. Fisher as National Commissioner

Fisher’s Influence on Scouting

Fisher’s earlier youth involvement was with the YMCA. He served as President of their International Physical Directors society from 1904 to 1919.

William Murray, Charter Member of the BSA Executive Board, wrote extensively of Fisher’s contribution to Scouting. In Murray’s book, The History of the Boy Scouts of America (1937), he covers the first twenty-five years of the BSA. He references Fisher’s leadership and operational involvement with nearly twenty-four references.

Fisher was involved in the creation of the original twelve regions and building the Field Committee for the BSA. Per Murray, Fisher “had been from the beginning, an active volunteer in Scouting and had been first Chairman of the Committee on Badges, Awards, Scout Requirements and Uniform Design” (p. 149).

Fisher retained this position from 1943 until is passing in 1960.

The 400,000th Picture – 2nd National Commissioner patch

So here is our 400,00th picture of Scout patches we have taken. You can see Fisher wearing it in the black and white picture above. Here it is in full color.

Collecting Boy Scout Council Shoulder Patches – CSPs

Posted on September 14th, 2023 in Baden-Powell,BSA Info,CSP,Jamborees,Legacy Interviews,RWS by ramore

We are handling the council shoulder patch collection for long time collector Bob Walton of North Carolina. The collection is special in it’s own right. It is among the top 5 (3?) such collections in the country and arguably the deepest in some of its specific themes. It is what we call a “generational collection” as it represents over 20 years of collecting. His collection is near complete in first issue CSPs. I call these the “rookie cards” of the hobby. His collection includes virtually all of the toughest of first issues. It is one of the most extensive Eagle Scout CSP collections we have ever seen (and we’ve seen a lot.)

But I’m burying the lede here. What is the most significant message here is that we are not selling this for Bob. We are selling it for Cape Fear Council, BSA. Bob has donated this whole collection to the Scouts for the council’s restricted endowment fund! He will be helping the hobby as today’s collectors will have a chance to pick up needs that rarely come available as there are so few. He will also be helping to assure that Scouting continues going forward developing today’s youth that will become tomorrow’s leaders!

While Bob was here we shot a couple of interviews. The first part discusses his collecting history and a few of the special issues in his collection.

Attending the 1957 Jamborees

In the first part Bob mentions starting his collecting in 1981 at the BSA National Jamboree that year. This wasn’t his first jamboree. Bob attended the 1957 BSA National Jamboree AND the 1957 World Jamboree! We did a second part where we go over those experiences and what it was like to start from Valley Forge and head to England and Europe.

The 1957 World Jamboree was an “extra” jamboree (my term). The prior World Jamboree was in 1955. Normally jamborees are four years apart. What made 1957 special is it was the 50th anniversary of the founding of Scouting and the 100th anniversary of the birth of Lord Baden Powell. Bob recounts seeing the young Queen Elizabeth and her husband Prince Phillip as they toured the entire jamboree site as well as other signatory experiences that such an event offers to the world’s youth.

Here’s the video.

Scouting Teaches Needed Life Skills

Posted on November 22nd, 2022 in BSA Info,General Commentary on Life by ramore

What life skills do you think should be taught in school?

This was a question posed by the Twitter member “World of Engineering”. What follows are some of the responses that had high “likes”. This is sort of like a mini focus group (although they have 1.7 million members.) Many of these needs we address within Scouting but today’s parents might not know that we do.

What life skills do you think should be taught in school?

  • Basic sewing, basic diet information about healthy food, cooking, first aid, how to take vitals and what they mean, basic exercise/stretching, injury/disease avoidance, caring for very young or old people (I’m a nurse, like you hadn’t noticed) (319 likes)
  • Personal finance should be mandatory – how to save, budget and invest. Statistics, economics, multi-digit mental math (none of this memorize or show your work BS), basic home repairs, cooking (74 )
  • Personal finance, understanding pay stub deductions, credit score, loans, just how to be fiscally responsible. (84)
  • Logical reasoning (e.g. common fallacies) and statistics. (1,152 likes)
  • Filing taxes Job interview skills Relationships Parenting Changing a tire & car maintenance Home maintenance Insurance Entrepreneurship Time management Sales and negotiation Stress management (139)
  • A class on “decision making in real life” and the biases that govern it (144)
  • How to do taxes, how to repair cars, how to cook, just to name a few (118) (a response included: Life Skills should start in 5th grade. )
  • How to survive in wild life. How to light a fire, how to protect their selfs from wild animals, how to find simple foods to survive or how to find fresh water. Imo after these lessons they will not cry for every simple things. (116)
  • Life essentials, not everyone has parents who can explain everything for their kids… (154)
  • Civics. Defense of democracy. The many ways to cook an egg. Basic electrical circuits and house wiring. Plumbing repairs wouldn’t hurt. How to clean a home. How to be kind. (8)
  • CPR and first aid, looking after your finances, driving lessons followed by a advanced driving course, are just some. Probably more importantly, get them to think for themselves, and think outside the ‘box’, let them use their own imagination. (30)

Words from a girl Eagle Scout

Posted on November 22nd, 2022 in BSA Info,Hobby Trends,Legacy Interviews by ramore

We are heading into Thanksgiving. This came across from the Scouts from a girl Eagle Scout who was the  first-place winner in the Central Florida Council scholarship contest. Worth reading and sharing.

She said,

“Leaders have to make decisions, be problem solvers, face adversity, and follow their moral obligations – all principles of Scouting. … Teaching young girls and boys the values of responsibility, loyalty, leadership, and camaraderie at this age equips them for life in the reality we live in. In the ever-changing society that we are a part of, these characteristics are fundamental for children to possess and carry with them into adulthood.

“The Scout stands for pride, integrity, opportunity, strength, freedom, and the true meaning of being an American, as they embody the flag on the uniform. Scouting instills these values into young Americans who will grow up with respect for their country, only building upon it as they age. … Scouts are our future, and they are equipped with a skill set that gives me confidence and faith in the future of our country.”

Here’s a link to the full essay. Eagle Scout essay contest winner.

Destry was recently at a trade-o-ree here in Michigan held at Camp Gerber. There was a camporee also going on at the camp. He shared that a number of boy and girl Eagle Scouts came through. Destry’s a class of ’85 Eagle Scout. He got to chatting with them. This was the first time he had had chance to talk much with girl Eagle Scouts. He shared that all the Eagle Scouts were impressive but was particularly struck with how impressive the girls were. He noted that many were quite appreciative of the opportunity to be in Scouts/BSA and really enjoyed their trail to Eagle.

Silver Bay – BSA’s Brownsea

Posted on August 19th, 2021 in Baden-Powell,BSA Info,Camps,Hobby News by ramore

The first BSA camp was held at the YMCA’s Silver Bay facility near Lake George, NY from August 16 – September 1, 1910. Like what Baden-Powell did earlier in England at Brownsea Island, the Scout leaders tested out the concept and interest in a summer camp experience for youth.

Pictures from the Silver Bay Camp from the Paul Freitag Museum, Buffalo, NY. Note the Seton Woodcraft Indians flag behind the Scouts in the campfire ring. Lower left shows Dan Beard teaching axe throwing.

In the earliest days of the BSA, before James West was hired as Chief Scout Executive, it was Edgar Robinson Director of the YMCA in New York city, that was helping to administer the developing organization. Actually, Robinson was involved in the selection, recruitment and hiring of West.

From the BSA National Jamboree Silver Bay exhibit syllabus:

… in 1910 Robinson, Seton (Founder of the Woodcraft Indians) and others, like Dan Beard (Founder of Sons of Daniel Boone), had become national leaders in founding the Boy Scouts of America. This caused camp plans to shift, and an experimental Woodcraft Boy Scout Camp resulted.

Campers were instructed in advance on what equipment was needed for camp through the YMCA newsletter Association Boys. Among the items listed were a ‘khaki suit and khaki hat.’ This was the first effort toward any type of standard uniform for American Scouts.

Campers were told to bring five books with them to camp. Besides the Bible, there was Alice Fletcher’s book on Indian stories and songs, and Horace Kephart’s classic on camping. Both authors were considered the leading experts in their fields. Seton’s Birch Bark Roll and Baden-Powell’s Scouting for Boys were also listed. But by the time of the camp, the BSA’s first Handbook for Boys had come out. The new handbook combined parts of The Birch Bark Roll and Scouting for Boys into one book and credited both men. Several copies of the first Handbook for Boys were brought to the camp.

From Silver Bay syllabus excerpt courtesy of staff director Kelly Williams
YMCA Silver Bay facility in more modern times (about 15 years ago). The 1910 campfire ring can still be seen. It is to the left in the photo in the woods near the shoreline
of the lake. Picture courtesy of Kelly Williams.

Silver Buffalo Certificates

Posted on July 1st, 2021 in Adult Position Badges,BSA Info,Insignia,Legacy Interviews by ramore

The Silver Buffalo and Silver Antelope awards were the first outstanding service awards issued by the BSA. They were first issued in 1926 and pre-date the Silver Beaver by five years.

This is not much of a collected area because they so seldom surface. The medals have been more documented than the certificates. We do though have a couple of them and thought we would share. The oldest certificate we have is from 1976 for Milton Caniff (of “Terry and the Pirates” cartoon fame).

Cartoonist and Eagle Scout Milton Caniff Silver Buffalo certificate

A more recent one we have is for President Ronald Reagan. Obviously the Honorary President did not sign this certificate as he was the Honorary President at the time.

President and Honorary BSA President Ronald Reagan Silver Buffalo cedrtificate

At the 2020 Dallas Trade-o-ree I shot an interview with BSA graphic artist Michael Feigenbaum. In one of them, we talked about the work he did in re-designing the recognition certificates.

And no where near the same level of significance, here is an example of a modern Silver Antelope certificate.

Passing of a great collector – Dr. Bill Kern

Posted on January 15th, 2020 in BSA Info,General Commentary on Life,Hobby News,Legacy Interviews by ramore
Bill is second from left at Scout summer camp circa 1940s.

A Passing of Note: William A. Kern, M.D. F.A.C.S. 6/6/1933 – 5/24-2019 (published in ISCA’s journal March, 2020).

Scout collector Bill Kern passed in May 24, 2019 at age 85 after a long and debilitating battle with Parkinson’s Disease.

For nearly eighty years Dr. Kern dedicated his life and lived by the Boy Scout Oath and Law. He joined the Cubs Scouts in the early forties, earning the Wolf and Bear ranks, with many Arrow Points while at Pack 19 in Hazelton, Pennsylvania. When his family moved to Frackville, Pennsylvania he joined Pack 591. He was the Den Leader and earned The Lion Award with eight more Arrow Points. He was among the first Cubs to earn The Arrow of Light Award.

He joined Troop 91 and progressed through the ranks in the minimum time earning the Eagle Rank with Bronze, Gold and three Silver Palms. During this time he served as Quarter Master, Scribe, Assistant Patrol Leader, Patrol Leader Assistant, Patrol Leader, and Assistant Scoutmaster. During the war he earned The Mac Arthur and Eisenhower Awards. In addition to serving in The Observer Corp he was a member of the troop band. He was also The Captain, and twice winner, of the First Aid Team at the TRI Council First Aid Meet, which had a great influence in his eventual decision to become a physician.

He was a six year camper attending Philmont Scout Ranch as a Scout and later served on the Camp Staff for two years. He was named Outstanding Scout for his council in 1946 and was elected into The Order of The Arrow and was selected for Senior Patrol Leader while attending the 1950 National Scout Jamboree.

During Bill’s college days at Penn State he was active in Alpha Phi Omega, plus helping with a local troop while also attaining grades to be selected to Phi Beta Kappa and Phi Delta MU, Honorary Scholastic Fraternities. He was also president of the Student Council and Vice President of his fraternity, Kappa Delta Roe. He maintained his busy schedule during his Post Graduate Training and Army Tours as Assistant Scoutmaster, Merit Badge Counselor and was a member of The Knights of Dunamis.

He received his medical degree from Temple Medical School in Philadelphia. Bill served in the U.S. Army, achieving the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. He served in Germany with the 11th Armored Calvary Regiment, and in Vietnam with the 24th Evacuation Hospital as the Chief Ophthalmic Adviser to the U.S. Surgeon General: 1967-68. He was awarded The Bronze Star during Tet Offensive.

He was a founding partner of Hemet Eye Medical and Surgical Center in Hemet, CA. He was a pioneer in outpatient cataract (inter-occular lens) surgery and glaucoma specialist. In the community he rose to become a 32nd Degree Mason.

It was in California with his sons Bill Jr. and Howard where he reconnected to Scouting serving with California Inland Empire Council. He received his Brotherhood and Vigil from Cahuilla Lodge 127.

Bill was passionate in many ways including his collecting of Scout patches which he picked up from Howard. The article above mentions his Eagle Scout collection was one of the reference sources for the first catalog of Eagle medals but he also built one of the best OA collections along with California camp patch collections and K of D collections in the country. Two of his sons are Eagle Scouts (Bill Jr., and Howard) and two grandsons are Eagle Scouts (Brandon and William A. Kern,III – B. T.) His spirit and joy of life will be missed.

Changes to Northern Illinois and Indiana Councils

Posted on August 1st, 2014 in BSA Info,Hobby News,Hobby Trends by ramore

Received this update from Central Region:

August 1, 2014
To:                          Central Region Executive Committee
                                Central Region Area 7 Committee
                                Chicago Area Council Key Three
                                Three Fires Council Key Three
                                Northeast Illinois Council Key Three
Des Plaines Council Key Three
Calumet Council Key Three
Blackhawk Area Council Key Three
Rainbow Council Key Three
Northwest Suburban Council Key Three
                                Central Region Area Directors
From:                    Brian Williams, Central Region President
                                Reid Christopherson, Central Region Commissioner
                                Al Lambert, Central Region Director
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
After much research, discussion, and deliberation, the Central Region Executive Committee has adopted a multi-phase approach to the realignment of councils in the Chicago/Northwest Indiana Metropolitan area.
As Phase One, the geographical territory currently being served by Northwest Suburban Council, Chicago Area Council, Calumet Council and Des Plaines Valley Council will be assigned to a new council that will be created within the boundaries of these four councils.
It is believed that this new council, operating within these approved boundaries, will successfully position Scouting in the Chicago/Northwest Indiana Metropolitan area for the future.  This new council will be constructed and fully operational by early in the first quarter of 2015.  Until that time, the four legacy councils will continue to operate and should continue to provide the services necessary to support their Scouts and families.
The Central Region Executive Board will provide interim governance and support for the newly created council.   National Executive Board member Ray Wood has been appointed to lead our support of the legacy councils during the transition.  Ray’s committee will include representatives of both the National Executive Board and our Regional Board.  Deputy Regional Director Fred Wallace has been appointed to lead the daily operations of the new council during the build out and will replace Matt Thornton as interim Scout Executive in our legacy councils.    You will hear from Ray and Fred shortly.
Phase Two of the project will begin later in 2015.  During this phase we will look at the councils and the territory surrounding the new council and will continue to explore the best alignment of communities aligned to provide strong Scouting programs to more youth.  Some of these could include:
·         A review of the territory served by the Rainbow Council including potential consolidation, collaboration and/or shared resources.
·         A review of the territory served by the Blackhawk Area Council, Three Fires Council and Northeast Illinois Council which could include discussions of consolidation, collaboration, shared resources, and boundary realignment.
·         A review of the Wisconsin and Iowa territory included in Area 7 and Area 3 to determine if those counties are being served in the best possible manner.
·         Other areas of review as determined.
While there will be much to discuss as the new council is built, we look forward to the Area 7 committee engaging with you to insure that every youth has an opportunity to join a strong program this fall.  This is surely the Main Thing…more youth across Area 7 experiencing the fun and adventure of Scouting.  Mike Duffee and Ernie Froemel continue to provide strong leadership to Area 7 – please count on them.
A sincere thank you is extended to the multitude of volunteers and professionals that have participated in the consolidation talks the past two years.  Your input was invaluable throughout this process.

BSA National Volunteer President Robert Gates’ remarks to 5/22 National Meeting

Posted on May 27th, 2014 in BSA Info by ramore

Here is the text of incoming National BSA President Robert Gates to the Boy Scouts of America National Meeting in Nashville, TN on May 22nd.

REMARKS

DR. ROBERT GATES

PRESIDENT, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA

NATIONAL ANNUAL MEETING

MAY 22, 2014

I AM DEEPLY HONORED BY YOUR VOTE OF CONFIDENCE IN ELECTING ME AS NATIONAL PRESIDENT OF

THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA. I HAVE BEEN PRIVILEGED TO HOLD A NUMBER OF HIGH-RANKINGPOSITIONS IN MY LIFE, BUT NONE MEANS MORE THAN TO LEAD THE ORGANIZATION THAT,

FOR ME, ENABLED ALL THE REST. FOR IT WAS AS A BOY SCOUT THAT I LEARNED THE BASIC PRINCIPLES OF LEADERSHIP.

NOW, AS AN ASIDE, I MUST SHARE WITH YOU THAT MY BECOMING NATIONAL PRESIDENT AFTER A CAREER IN CIA BRINGS SCOUTING FULL CIRCLE BECAUSE, YOU SEE, ROBERTBADEN POWELL DURING HIS MILITARY CAREER SERVED AS A SPY. HE WORKED FOR THE BRITISH DIRECTOR OF MILITARY INTELLIGENCE AND OPERATING UNDER COVER IN THE MEDITERREAN, SOMETIMES POSED AS A

BUTTERFLY COLLECTOR. HE ONCE SAID, “FOR ANYONE TIRED OF LIFE, THE THRILLING LIFE OF A SPY SHOULD BE THE VERY FINEST RECUPERATOR.” HE DID PIONEERING WORK IN RECONNAISSANCE, OR AS THE MILITARY THEN CALLED IT, SCOUTING. JUST A BIT OF TRIVIA WITH WHICH YOU CAN WIN SMALL BETS.

BEFORE I GO ANY FURTHER, LET ME THANK WAYNE PERRY FOR HIS DYNAMIC AND HISTORIC LEADERSHIP DURING A PERIOD OF CHALLENGE FOR THE BOY SCOUTS. WAYNE, WE ALL OWE YOU A GREAT DEBT OF GRATITUDE FOR YOUR REMARKABLE SERVICE, YOUR DEVOTION TO THIS MOVEMENT AND YOUR STEADY HAND OVER THE PAST TWO YEARS. I KNOW THERE WERE COUNTLESS VOLUNTEERS IN MAKING THE FIRST-EVER NATIONAL JAMBOREE AT THE SUMMIT A HUGE SUCCESS, BUT IT WAS

YOUR VISION AND DRIVE THAT GOT US THERE.

A FEW WORDS ABOUT MY SCOUTING RESUME. SCOUTING WAS A BIG PART OF MY LIFE GROWING UP. I

HAVE A PHOTOGRAPH OF MY FATHER IN HIS BOY SCOUT UNIFORM IN FRONT OF HIS HOUSE IN KANSAS CITY, A PHOTGRAPH TAKEN IN 1918. THERE WAS NEVER ANY QUESTION IN OUR HOUSE ABOUT JOINING THE SCOUTS. I WAS A CUB SCOUT, BOY SCOUT AND EXPLORER SCOUT IN QUIVERA COUNCIL IN WICHITA, KANSAS. MY OLDER BROTHER AND I ARE BOTH EAGLE SCOUTS AND ALSO BOTH

EARNED OUR GOD AND COUNTRY AWARD. WE BOTH ATTENDED NATIONAL JAMBOREES AT VALLEY FORGE, HE IN 1950 AND I IN 1957. I RECEIVED MY VIGIL HONOR IN THE ORDER OF THE ARROW IN HI-CHAKO-LO LODGE IN WICHITA. I REMAINED ACTIVE IN SCOUTING AS A COLLEGE STUDENT, SERVING AS AN ASSISTANT SCOUTMASTER IN WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA. AND THEN I WENT MISSING FOR THIRTY YEARS.

OH, MY SON WAS A SCOUT DURING MUCH OF THE TIME I WAS DIRECTOR OF CIA. I’LL NEVER FORGET THE FATHER-AND-SON WILDERNESS CAMP-OUT NEAR CHESAPEAKE BAY. I THINK THE WILDERNESS ASPECT OF THE OVERNIGHTER WAS PROBABLYDIMINISHED BY THE TWO LARGE BLACK TRUCKS WITH SATELLITE DISHES PARKED NEARBY AND THE FACT THAT CIA OFFICERS ESTABLISHED A SECURITY

PERIMETER AROUND THE ENTIRE CAMP. TO MY SECURITY OFFICERS’ CHAGRIN, THE SUNDAY MORNING ACTIVITY WAS TEACHING THE KIDS HOW TO SHOOT SKEET –JUST WHAT THE SECURITY GUYS WANTED: ME, THE CIA DIRECTOR, IN THE MIDST OF A BUNCH OF 12 AND 13 YEAR OLDS WITH SHOTGUNS.

WHEN I RETIRED AS CIA DIRECTOR IN 1993, I WAS APPROACHED ABOUT JOINING THE BOARD OF THE

NATIONAL CAPITAL AREA COUNCIL.WHEN PEOPLE ASKED WHY I HAD BEEN INACTIVE FOR SO LONG, I REPLIED IMPLY, “BECAUSE NO ONE ASKED ME TO HELP.” AND THAT WAS BEHIND THE EFFORT I STARTED IN THE MID-1990S AS PRESIDENT OF THE NATIONAL EAGLE SCOUT ASSOCIATION

TO IDENTIFY, LOCATE AND TRY TO RE-ENLIST ADULT EAGLE SCOUTS ALL OVER THE COUNTRY WHO WERE INACTIVE IN SCOUTING. WE COULD NOT –AND CANNOT –AFFORD TO HAVE SUCH MEN SAY I HAVEN’T RE-ENGAGED BECAUSE NOBODY ASKED ME.

NOT LONG AFTER I RETIRED AS SECRETARY OF DEFENSE IN THE SUMMER OF 2011, THE LONG ARM OF

SCOUTING REACHED OUT AGAIN. IT HAS A WAY OF DOING THAT. I ELUDED THE ARM FOR A WHILE, BUT IT SOON BECAME APPARENT THAT RESISTANCE WAS FUTILE. AND SO I STAND BEFORE YOU TODAY MAKING MY FIRST SPEECH TO A NATIONAL GATHERING OF SCOUTS SINCE THE 2010 JAMBOREE.

WHY AM I HERE? SIMPLY BECAUSE I CONTINUE TO BELIEVE, AS I HAVE THROUGHOUT MY LIFE, THAT THERE IS NO FINER PROGRAM FOR PREPARING AMERICAN BOYS AND YOUNG MEN FOR LEADERSHIP THAN THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA.

FIFTY-FIVE YEARS AGO, WHEN I RECEIVED MY EAGLE, I WAS A FIFTEEN YEAR OLD BOY ATTENDING HIGH SCHOOL. I WASN’T A STRAIGHT A STUDENT, NOR WAS I A PARTICULARLY GOOD ATHLETE. ALTHOUGH I WAS INVOLVED IN SCHOOL ACTIVITIES, I WASN’T REALLY A STUDENT LEADER. THIS WAS ALL TRUE IN COLLEGE AS WELL. WHEN I WENT TO WASHINGTON, D.C. AT AGE 22, I COULD FIT EVERYTHING I OWNED INTO THE BACKSEAT OF MY CAR. I HAD NO CONNECTIONS AND I DIDN’T KNOW A SOUL. THE ONLY THING I HAD DONE IN MY LIFE TO THAT POINT THAT LED ME TO THINK I COULD MAKE A DIFFERENCE,

THAT I COULD BE A LEADER, WAS TO EARN MY EAGLE SCOUT BADGE. IT WAS THE ONLY THING I HAD

DONE THAT DIFFERENTIATED ME FROM SO MANY OTHER HIGH SCHOOL KIDS. IT WAS THE FIRST THING I HAD DONE THAT TOLD ME I MIGHT BE DIFFERENT BECAUSE I HAD WORKED HARDER, WAS MORE DETERMINED, MORE GOAL-ORIENTED, MORE PERSISTENT THAN MOST OTHERS.

EARNING MY EAGLE GAVE ME THE SELF CONFIDENCE TO BELIEVE, FOR THE FIRST TIME IN MY LIFE, THAT I COULD ACHIEVE WHATEVER I SET MY MIND TO. MY EAGLE AWARD WAS THE FIRST AND MOST IMPORTANT STEP, TOWARD EVERYTHING I WOULD LATER ACCOMPLISH.

I ALSO AGREED TO SERVE AS PRESIDENT OF THE BOY SCOUTS BECAUSE THE INSTITUTION THAT PLAYED SUCH AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN SHAPING MY LIFE TODAY FACES SOME DAUNTING CHALLENGES.

WHEN PRESIDENT BUSH ASKED ME TO BECOME SECRETARY OF DEFENSE IN 2006 WE WERE LOSING TWO WARS. I TOLD HIM,“IF YOU THINK I CAN HELP, IT IS MY DUTY TO DO SO.” IF ALL OF YOU THINK I CAN HELP SCOUTING, THEN IT IS MY DUTY TO DO SO.

I HAVE A REPUTATION FOR BLUNTNESS AND CANDOR. AS I USED TO TELL FOREIGN LEADERS WHO WERE TAKEN ABACK BY MY PLAIN TALK, IF I HAD WANTED TO BE A DIPLOMAT, I’D HAVE JOINED THE STATE DEPARTMENT — NOT CIA. MY BLUNTNESS MAY DISTURB SOME OF YOU, BUT IT’S PART OF THE PACKAGE. AND MAYBE IT’S TIME FOR BLUNT TALK.

LET ME SAY RIGHT HERE THAT AS PRESIDENT OF THE NATIONAL EAGLE SCOUT ASSOCIATION AND MEMBER OF THE BOARD BETWEEN 1997 AND 2006, I WAS HARSHLY CRITICAL OF THE WAY THIS ORGANIZATION WAS RUN. I FREQUENTLY DESCRIBED MEETINGS OF THE BOARD AS HAVING ALL THE SPONTANEITY OF A MEETING OF THE SUPREME SOVIET OR OF THE CHINESE COMMUNIST CENTRAL COMMITTEE. EVERYTHING SEEMED SCRIPTED AND THE VOLUNTEER LEADERS SEEMED TO ME TO BE

LARGELY FIGUREHEADS. ON RETURNING TO THE BOARD, I BELIEVE ALL THAT HAS CHANGED DRAMATICALLY. THANKS TO THE LEADERSHIP OF REX TILLERSON, WAYNE PERRY, BOB

MAZUCCA, WAYNE BROCK AND MANY OTHERS, I BELIEVE THE VOLUNTEER LEADERSHIP HAS ASSUMED ITS PROPER ROLE AS THE GUIDING HAND OF THIS MOVEMENT.

THERE IS STILL ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT, BUT AS SOMEONE WHO HAS NOT BEEN INVOLVED FOR THE PAST EIGHT YEARS, THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THEN AND NOW IS LIKE NIGHT AND DAY.

IN EACH ORGANIZATION I HAVE LED, MY GOAL HAS BEEN TO MAKE GOOD INSTITUTIONS BETTER. IF YOU WANTED THE STATUS QUO, YOU SURELY GOT THE WRONG GUY. SO, WHAT WILL BE MY PRIORITIES DURING THE TWO YEAR TERM I WILL SERVE AS PRESIDENT?

FIRST, TO CONTINUE TO IMPROVE TRANSPARENCY IN THE VOLUNTEER GOVERNANCE OF SCOUTING. THE BSA IS NOT THE CIA. WE SHOULD HAVE NO SECRETS FROM EACH OTHER OR FROM OUR VOLUNTEERLEADERS ACROSS THE NATION. THE BOARD HAS ASKED AUBREY HARWELL TO

CHAIR AN AD HOC COMMITTEE TO LOOK AT OUR BY-LAWS, REGULATIONS AND GOVERNANCE.

AMONG OTHER THINGS, I WANT AUBREY’S GROUP TO LOOK AT HOW WE CAN BE MORE TRANSPARENT TO VOLUNTEERS NATIONWIDE ABOUT ALL ASPECTS OF OUR OPERATIONS.

I INTEND TO MAKE THAT AN IMPORTANT PRIORITY. A SECOND PRIORITY IS TO IMPROVE OUR MARKETING, WHICH IN TURN IS CLOSELY TIED TO RECRUITMENT AND TO OUR REPUTATION. I BELIEVE THAT THE LION’S SHARE OF OUR MARKETING – AND OUR SPENDING ON MARKETING – SHOULD BE LOCAL. THE SUCCESS OR FAILURE OF IMPROVING COUNCIL FINANCES AND RECRUITMENT OF BOTH BOYS AND ADULT VOLUNTEERS DEPENDS ON LOCAL ACTION AND LOCAL SUPPORT.

LET’S FACE IT, THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA IS NOT LIKELY TO GET MUCH FAVORABLE PUBLICITY AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL. FIRST OF ALL, YOU MAY HAVE NOTICED THAT THE NATIONAL MEDIA ISN’T MUCH INTO REPORTING GOOD NEWSOF ANY KIND. FURTHER, I BELIEVE MARKETING AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL IS NOT VERY USEFUL EITHER IN TERMS OF RECRUITMENT OR FUND – RAISING FOR COUNCILS.

RECRUITMENT FOR SURE, AND MOST FUND – RAISING, MUST BE DONE RETAIL – ONE FAMILY AT A TIME, ONE DONOR AT A TIME, AND BOTH FACE-TO-FACE.

I THINK OUR MARKETING NEEDS TO BE FOCUSED ON LOCAL MEDIA – WHETHER TRADITIONAL LOCAL

TELEVISION AND NEWSPAPERS OR SOCIAL MEDIA. EVERY DAY, IN EVERY DISTRICT AND EVERY COUNCIL, THERE ARE COUNTLESS GOOD NEWS STORIES ABOUT SCOUTING, FROM EAGLE PROJECTS AND SCOUT SERVICE PROJECTS HELPING THE COMMUNITY TO SCOUTS HELPING OUT DURING NATURAL DISASTERS

  • SUCH AS SCOUTS DID AFTER THE HORRIFIC MUDSLIDE IN OSO, WASHINGTON , NOT TOO FAR

FROM WHERE I LIVE. FOCUSING ON GETTING THESE STORIES LOCAL PUBLICITY ON A CONTINUING BASIS SEEMS TO ME A WAY TO INTEGRATE LOCAL MARKETING WITH LOCAL RECRUITMENT AND FUND -RAISING.

FOR THE MOST PART, THE ROLE OF THE NATIONAL OFFICE SHOULD BE TO DEVELOP AND MAKE AVAILABLE TO COUNCILS THE MEDIA TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES THEY MAY FIND USEFUL.

MANY COUNCIL SCOUT EXECUTIVES AND PROFESSIONALS ARE UNEASY ABOUT ENGAGING WITH

LOCAL MEDIA BECAUSE THEY ARE SO OFTEN FOCUSED ON SUBJECTS LIKE MEMBERSHIP POLICY OR PAST ABUSE. SO, MAYBE WE OUGHT TO THINK ABOUT HOW TO ENGAGE LOCAL VOLUNTEER LEADERS IN REACHING OUT TO LOCAL MEDIA WITH STORIES ABOUT OUR SCOUTS DOING GREAT THINGS FOR THAT COMMUNITY. AND ABOUT WHY FAMILIES NEED SCOUTING IN THEIR LIVES. REPORTERS ARE

A LOT LESS LIKELY TO CONFRONT PARENTS OR VOLUNTEERS WITH NATIONAL POLICY ISSUES THAN SCOUT PROFESSIONALS.

SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE TIP O’NEILL FAMOUSLY SAID THAT ALL POLITICS IS LOCAL. I WOULD PARAPHRASE THAT TO SAY ALL RECRUITMENT AND NEARLY ALL POSITIVE SCOUT STORIES ARE LOCAL– AND I THINK THE TWO ARE RELATED. SO, UNDER THE LEADERSHIP OF NEW VICE PRESIDENT FOR MARKETING DAVID WEEKLY, LET’S THINK ABOUT HOW BETTER TO ENABLE LOCAL SCOUT COUNCILS AND DISTRICTS TO GET THE WORD OUT ABOUT ALL THE GOOD THEY ARE DOING.

NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS SHOULD BE AN ENABLER, NOT THE DRIVER.

I’VE MENTIONED RECRUITMENT SEVERAL TIMES. WE ALL KNOW THE DOWNWARD DIRECTION OF OUR MEMBERSHIP NUMBERS. WE MUST FIRST STOP THE DECLINE AND THEN BEGIN TO ADDRESS HOW WE GROW AGAIN. I DON’T HAVE ANY EASY ANSWERS TO THIS CHALLENGE. I DO BELIEVE IT STARTS WITH EMPHASIS ON RECRUITING CUB SCOUTS. TEACHING LEADERSHIP AND SKILLS ARE IMPORTANT REASONS FOR JOINING SCOUTS FOR ALL OF US, BUT I SUSPECT THAT FOR MOST PARENTS OF BOYS OF CUB SCOUT AGE, WHAT THEY WANT MOST OF ALL IS A CHANCE TO SPEND TIME WITH THEIR KIDS. UNLIKE

MANY OTHER ACTIVITIES AVAILABLE TO BOYS, SCOUTING OFFERS PARENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE FULLY ENGAGED SIDE-BY-SIDE WITH THEIR CHILD – NOT JUST CHEERING FROM THE SIDELINES. PERHAPS WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW BETTER TO GET THAT ACROSS TO PEOPLE. IF WE CAN GET BOYS INTO CUBSCOUTS, OUR ROLE MODELS, THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE A WORLD THEY WOULD NEVER OTHERWISE SEE AND FUTURES THEY NEVER THOUGHT POSSIBLE. AT EVERY LEVEL OF SCOUTING,

EXPANDING SCOUTREACH NEEDS TO BE A RENEWED PRIORITY FOR US. WHETHER RECRUITING OR FUND RAISING, WE NEED RENEWEDEMPHASIS ON BUILDING STRONGER RELATIONSHIPS IN OUR COMMUNITIES – WITH SCHOOLS, OTHER NOT-FOR-PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS, CHURCHES, AND CIVIC, SERVICE AND VETERANS’ ORGANIZATIONS.

FURTHER, WE NEED TO BE FAR MORE AGGRESSIVE IN RECRUITING HISPANIC, AFRICAN-AMERICAN AND ASIAN-AMERICAN COMMUNITY LEADERS TO OUR COUNCIL, REGIONAL AND NATIONAL BOARDS. NOTHING WILL HELP OUR RECRUITMENT IN THESE COMMUNITIES MORE THAN TO HAVE SUCH LEADERS INVOLVED IN AND AS ADVOCATES FOR SCOUTING.

WE HAVE PREVIOUSLY TALKED THE TALK. NOW IT IS TIME TO WALK THE WALK.

ALSO KEY TO RECRUITMENT IS CONTINUED PROGRAM INNOVATION TO ENSURE THAT SCOUTING REMAINS RELEVANT TO BOYS AND YOUNG MEN IN THE 21ST CENTURY. I STRONGLY SUPPORT THE STEM INITIATIVE ON ITS OWN MERITS BUT ALSO BECAUSE PARENTS ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE DRAWN TO A PROGRAM THAT, IN ADDITION TO BEING FUN, WILL HELP THEIR SONSAND DAUGHTERS DO BETTER IN SCHOOL.

A TWO YEAR TERM ISN’T A LONG TIME. TRANSPARENCY, MARKETING, RETENTION AND RECRUITMENT, CONTINUED PROGRAM INNOVATION. THESE WILL BE MY PRIORITIES.

PLUS ONE OTHER. IN EACH INSTITUTION I HAVE LED – CIA AND THE AMERICAN INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY, , TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY, THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE – THERE HAS BEEN TENSION

BETWEEN THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATION OR HEADQUARTERS AND THE FIELD. THUS, THE TENSION

BETWEEN BSA’S NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS AND THE COUNCILS IS NEITHER UNIQUE NOR SURPRISING.

BUT I HAVE A STRONG PREDILECTION FOR EMPOWERING FIELD COMMANDERS – THOSE ON THE FRONT LINES – AND HOLDING THEM ACCOUNTABLE. THEY ARE THE ONES CHARGED WITH ACCOMPLISHING

THE MISSION – IN OUR CASE, RECRUITING BOYS AND VOLUNTEER LEADERS, RAISING FUNDS, AND DELIVERING A QUALITY PROGRAM.

I KNOW THAT THE DEDICATED PROFESSIONALS ON THE NATIONAL COUNCIL STAFF AGREE WITH THE EMPHASIS ON LOCAL COUNCIL SUPPORT. I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH WAYNE BROCK AND HIS TEAM TO REVIEW NATIONAL COUNCIL PROCEDURES, POLICIES AND REGULATIONS TO CONTINUE THE EFFORT TO MAKE OUR NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS A MORE EFFECTIVE AND RESPONSIVE SERVICE CENTER FOR COUNCILS — AN ASSET FOR THEM AND NOT A THORN IN THEIR SIDE.

INDEED, MAYBE WHAT IS NOW KNOWN AS THE BSA NATIONAL OFFICE OR HEADQUARTERS OUGHT TO BE RENAMED THE BSA NATIONAL SERVICE CENTER TO BE A CONSTANT REMINDER OF ITS MISSION.

AND I WANT TO HEAR FROM COUNCIL AND REGIONAL SCOUT EXECUTIVES AND BOARD PRESIDENTS IF THEY HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT THE QUALITY OR LEVEL OF SUPPORT THEY ARE RECEIVING FROM HEADQUARTERS – AND SUGGESTIONS FOR IMPROVING THAT SUPPORT OR OTHER CONCERNS ABOUT OUR MOVEMENT.

FOR THE FIRST TIME, THE NATIONAL PRESIDENT WILL HAVE A FULL TIME, INDEPENDENT REPRESENTATIVE AT SCOUT HEADQUARTERS TO HELP ME BE MORE EFFECTIVE FOR SCOUTING. CHARLES CRIMMINS HAS SUPPORTED ME FOR TWO YEARS IN MY ROLE AS CHANCELLOR OF THE COLLEGE OF WILLIAM AND MARY AND NOW WILL DO SO IN IRVING FOR MY SCOUTING ROLE. I URGE YOU TO MAKE HIS ACQUAINTANCE. DON’T HESITATE TO CONTACT CHARLES WITH YOUR SUGGESTIONS, CONCERNS AND ISSUES WHERE YOU THINK I CAN HELP. HE WILL BE THE FOCAL POINT FOR ALL COMMUNIATIONS WITH ME AND ALSO MY TRAVELS AROUND THE COUNTRY IN SUPPORT OF SCOUTING.

CHARLES, PLEASE STAND SO FOLKS CAN RECOGNIZE YOU.

FINALLY, LET ME ADDRESS THE MEMBERSHIP ISSUE, AN ISSUE THAT HAS LEFT US DIVIDED, DISTRACTED AND DEFENSIVE. A YEAR AGO, THIS MEETING SAW A RESPECTFUL AND CIVIL DEBATE OVER MEMBERSHIP POLICY.

IN A DEMOCRATIC PROCESS, A STRONG MAJORITY OF THE VOLUNTEER LEADERSHIP OF THIS MOVEMENT FROM ALL ACROSS THE NATION VOTED TO WELCOME GAY YOUTH INTO SCOUTING. IN ALL

CANDOR, I WOULD HAVE SUPPORTED GOING FURTHER, AS I DID IN OPENING THE WAY FOR GAYS TO SERVE IN CIA AND IN THE MILITARY. THAT SAID,I ACCEPT THE VOTE OF A YEAR AGO, AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT IT.

AND, IN ITS IMPLEMENTATION, SCOUTING MUST PROVIDE A WELCOMING AND SAFE ENVIRONMENT FOR GAY YOUTH, A PLACE WHERE THEY CAN BENEFIT FROM SCOUTING AND NOT FACE BULLYING OR DISRESPECT.

BUT, I ALSO BELIEVE STRONGLY THAT WE MUST PUT THIS ISSUE BEHIND US AND MOVE FORWARD, RE-FOCUSING OUR ENERGIES AND OUR PASSION ON MAKING SCOUTING AN EVEN BIGGER, BETTER PROGRAM FOR KIDS.

I AM, AS YOU MUST ALREADY KNOW, A HARD-EYED REALIST. GIVEN THE STRONG FEELINGS – THE PASSION – INVOLVED ON BOTH SIDES OF THIS MATTER, I BELIEVE STRONGLY THAT TO RE-OPEN THE MEMBERSHIP ISSUE OR TRY TO TAKE LAST YEAR’S DECISION TO THE NEXT STEP WOULD IRREPARABLY

FRACTURE AND PERHAPS EVEN PROVOKE A FORMAL, PERMANENT SPLIT IN THIS MOVEMENT — WITH THE HIGH LIKELIHOOD NEITHER SIDE WOULD SUBSEQUENTLY SURVIVE ON ITS OWN. THAT IS JUST A FACT OF LIFE.

AND WHO WOULD PAY THE PRICE FOR DESTROYING THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA? MILLIONS OF SCOUTS TODAY AND SCOUTS YET UNBORN. WE MUST ALWAYS PUT THE KIDS AND THEIR INTERES

TS FIRST. THUS, DURING MY TIME AS PRESIDENT, I WILL OPPOSE ANY EFFORT TO RE-OPEN THIS ISSUE.

NO ONE CAN FORETELL WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE BUT, NOW – AT THIS MOMENT IN OUR HISTORY – WE MUST MOVE FORWARDBY FOCUSING ON WHAT UNITES US: OUR BELIEF THAT THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA IS THE FINEST ORGANIZATION IN THE WORLD FOR BUILDING CHARACTER WHILE TEACHING BOYS AND YOUNG MEN TO MEET AND OVERCOME CHALLENGES, TO CHEERFULLY SERVE OTHERS, AND TO LIVE LIVES BASED ON THE PRINCIPLES OF THE SCOUT OATH AND LAW.

IT IS TIME TO FOCUS ON THE FUTURE, AND TO DO SO WITH CONFIDENCE AND HIGH EXPECTATIONS. WE ARE UNITED BECAUSE WE ALL BELIEVE IN THE EXTRAORDINARY POWER OF SCOUTING TO BE A FORCE FOR GOOD IN A COMMUNITY AND IN THE LIVES OF ITS BOYS AND YOUNG MEN. WE ARE UNITED BECAUSE WE ALL BELIEVE THAT EVERY BOY WHO JOINS THE SCOUTS IS A BOY ON THE RIGHT TRACK. WE ARE UNITED IN OUR VISION OF A COMMUNITY OF INVOLVED, COMMITTED ADULTS WHO PROVIDE THE CHANCE FOR EVERY BOY TO HAVE FRIENDS HIS OWN AGE WITH WHOM HE CAN CAMP AND LEARN AND

LAUGH, LED BY CARING ADULTS WHO SET AN EXAMPLE NOT JUST OF SKILLS, BUT OF CHARACTER

, OF THE JOY OF SERVICE, OF THE JOY OF LIFE. ADULTS WHO ARE LEADERS AND TEACH BOYS TO BE LEADERS.

AT THE END OF THE ORDER OF THE ARROW ORDEAL INITIATION CEREMONY, UNCAS, SON OF THE CHIEF OF THE DELAWARES, SAYS TO HIS FATHER, “IF WE WOULD REMAIN A NATION, WE MUST STAND BY ONE ANOTHER. LET US BOTH URGE ON OUR KINDRED FIRM DEVOTION TO OUR BRETHREN AND OUR CAUSE. OURSELVES FORGETTING, LET US CATCH THE HIGHER VISION. LET US FIND THE GREATER BEAUTY IN THE LIFE OF CHEERFUL SERVICE.”

IN CHALLENGING BOYS TO LEARN SKILLS, MASTER CHALLENGES AND TO STRIVE TO LIVE UP TO HIGH

PRINCIPLES AND MORAL VALUES, TO FIND THE GREATER BEAUTY IN A LIFE OF CHEERFUL SERVICE, TO BUILD STRONG CHARACTER, SCOUTING TEMPERS THEM AND TURNS THEM INTO STRONG LEADERS FOR TOMORROW. LEADERS WE DESPERATELY NEED.

SCOUTING’S GIFT TO AMERICA – ITS LEGACY – FOR OVER A CENTURY HAS BEEN ONE GENERATION AFTER ANOTHER OF WORTHY LEADERS FOR OUR COMMUNITIES AND FOR OUR COUNTRY. THE CHALLENGE BEFORE US, HERE TODAY AND GOING FORWARD, IS THE SAME THAT FACED OUR PREDECESSORS: IN THE WORDS OF UNCAS, “FIRM DEVOTION TO OUR BRETHREN AND OUR CAUSE” –TO SUSTAIN AND STRENGTHEN SCOUTING SO THAT IT CONTINUES TO PROVIDE FOR AMERICA SERVANT LEADERS OF CHARACTER, OF FAITH, OF SKILL, OF COURAGE.

RESOLUTE AND UNITED, THIS MUST BE OUR COMMITMENT.

THIS MUST BE OUR OATH.

THIS MUST BE OUR PRAYER.

THIS MUST BE OUR PARTING PLEDGE TO ONE ANOTHER.

GOD BLESS THE BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA, AND GOD BLESS AMERICA.

For Your Information by Paul Myers in ASTA

 

Senior collector Paul Myers of Goshen, IN was at the recent Calumet Council Memorial Day Trade-o-ree. Paul is a former editor of the Trader magazine in the 1960s. In the 1990s he wrote a regular column for ASTA, the America Scout Traders Association, which merged with NSCA to form ISCA the national group today. At the TOR Paul was handing out a compilation of the articles he wrote for ASTA. It is now contained in a PDF below. It covers over 75 topics of Scouting collectibles. Not in depth necessarily but my guess is that even veteran collectors will learn something knew from going through these pages.

The topics include:

  • Amaquonsippi trail patches
  • US Grant Pilgrimage patches
  • Lincoln Pilgrimage patches
  • Contest medals
  • Henderson Award System
  • Belt Stencils
  • Colored Background Service Stars
  • BSA Anniversary Week
  • Ribbon Pin Bars
  • 100% Duty
  • Standard Church Troop Bars
  • Original Twelve Regions
  • OA Chapter Flaps
  • Early Registration Cards
  • Scout Emergency Units
  • Recruiter Strips
  • Scout Diaries
  • Boy Rangers of America
  • District Badges
  • Region 7 Hoe Down
  • Sweater, swim suit, hat and jacket badges
  • Veteran Emblems
  • Explorer Top Awards
  • Presidents Awards & Quality Unit
  • SeniorScout Titles
  • Civic Service
  • Overseas Travel Badges
  • Service Library
  • WW 1 War Service Medals
  • National Service Camps
  • Boy Scout Bands
  • Tenure in Scout Camp
  • Service Troops
  • Jamboree Staff Positions
  • Jamboree Participation Awards
  • Jamboree Contingent items
  • Jamboree Shoulder Identification
  • 1950 Jamboree Prototypes
  • Variations in Jamboree Patches and Neckerchiefs
  • Jamboree Region Items
  • Strengthen the Arm of Liberty Program
  • Take Me Home Folders
  • Scout Straight Knives
  • Scoutmaster’s Key
  • Cub Scouting
  • First Class Hat Pins
  • Patrol Identification
  • Folding Pocket Knives
  • OA Chapter Badges
  • Scout Rings
  • Pin Back Buttons
  • State Strips
  • Early Camp Honor Societies
  • Philadelphia District Badges
  • Region Standard Camp Badges
  • Philmont Contingent Patches
  • Merit Badges
  • Boycraft Co. Booklets
  • 10 Year Program Award
  • Sea Scout Ships

Boy Scout Memorabilia Information


[sales] [forum] [reference] [about us] [contact] [home]

Copyright © 1999 - 2009